Voted the Best Pizza
In Southwest Michigan
Voted the Best Pizza
In Southwest Michigan
Voted the Best Pizza
In Southwest Michigan
Voted the Best Pizza
In Southwest Michigan

CARRYOUT TIPS: You will get a text when your order comes out of the oven. DO NOT get in line for carryout until you get the text! We do have four parking spots for carryout just past the parking lot check-in booth on the left for your convenience. There are two different pick-up spots we utilize for carryout depending on time of day. Please pay attention to the signage.

OUR PARKING LOT CAN BE A BIT OF A NIGHTMARE: It is long, skinny, and has only one entrance/exit. It is best to avoid it if you are dining in! Please be patient if you get caught in our lot. You will eventually escape, we promise! Also remember that our lot has a KEEP LEFT AT ALL TIMES traffic flow. This is to accommodate our curbside carryout. Just act British when you are in our lot and you will do just fine. CHEERIO MATE!

The Story of Silver Beach Pizza (The Schooner)

Story of Silver Beach Pizza (Schooner)

In 2003 the future owners of Silver Beach Pizza were on vacation. Jay and Tony went to a “locals” tavern in a nearby harbor and ordered a draft beer. The bartender reached down into a chest freezer, pulled out a frozen schooner, filled it with cold draft beer and set it in front of them. The most beautiful beer presentation the boys had ever seen was staring back at them. The “fog” was cascading around the glass and ice was forming on the outside.

They got excited about someday serving beer to people like that and talked about it often. Pizza wasn’t even a topic of conversation yet; it was all about the beer presentation. Tony owned a place in Saint Joseph and has loved the location. When he saw that the historic Amtrak Depot became available, the idea of opening it as a pizza place took shape. They obtained the lease in August, 2005. That ice cold schooner found a home alongside a really great pizza at Silver Beach Pizza.

Welcome to the Upper Deck!

The Upper Deck is an elevated structure that is a separate area from the downstairs dining at Silver Beach Pizza. The Upper Deck is adults only (21 and over – no babies please) and is reservations only. The Upper Deck has seating for about 60 and has its own bar. If you are having trouble getting a table for a certain day, that means we are full. Reservations can be made up to 2 weeks ahead of time.

$5 deposit per guest required for parties of 8 or more which will be refunded to your card when you show for your reservation

Note: Stairway access only to upper deck. Upper deck is 21 and over only – no babies please. Also please do not bring more people than you make a reservation for. Our seating is limited and most of our tables are not movable. Thanks!

Tips to Improve Your SBP Experience

Story of Silver Beach Pizza (Schooner)

Parking:
We do have a parking lot but it can be a bit of a nightmare. It is long and skinny with one entrance. We STRONGLY recommend you try to avoid it! There is a city lot just west of us. It is free from November 1 – March 31 and $5-10 otherwise. If you bring the little tear-off from the receipt, we will take $5 off your bill (like a coupon). You can also park on the bluff and walk down.

Get on Our Waitlist:
If we are on a wait, you can add your name to our waitlist and you will get a text when your table is ready. You can either add your name in person or by calling us, 269-983-4PIE (269-983-4743).

Takeout:
If there is a long wait (they can get up to 3 hours) we suggest you consider getting a takeout and enjoying it outside if the weather is nice.

We would love to hear from you!

Questions or Comments?

Email us by submitting the form below or call us at: (269) 983-4743

  • Please note, emails are monitored regularly but do not pop up at the restaurant. They go directly to the owners email.
Silver Beach Pizza 4.5 star rating 1341 reviews